When Erin Foster, creator and executive producer of Nobody Wants This, announced the return of the rom‑com series on October 23, 2025, almost everyone with a streaming account tuned in.
The sophomore season dropped on Netflix, the Los Gatos‑based streaming giant, and within days the show earned a Certified Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes — a striking 88‑89 % approval from critics.
Season 2 Launch and the Numbers Behind the Score
Exactly 13 months after the first episode aired on September 26, 2024, Season 2 premiered, delivering twelve 20‑minute episodes that follow sex‑podcaster Joanne Williams (played by Kristen Bell) as she settles into married life with Rabbi Noah Roklov (portrayed by Adam Brody). The initial aggregation on Rotten Tomatoes featured eight critic reviews, giving the season an 88 % Fresh score; a week later, after 19 reviews were logged, the figure nudged up to 89 %.
For comparison, Season 1 closed its run with a 95 % critic score and an 85 % audience rating, a performance that earned multiple Emmy nominations. The jump from eight to nineteen reviews in a single week shows how quickly the conversation around the series escalated.
Critical Consensus: What Reviewers Are Saying
Critics seem to agree on two things: the dialogue sparkles and the cultural clash feels genuine. Isabella Soares of Collider wrote, “Joanne and Noah are no longer in the honeymoon phase, and that’s why the series’ return feels like a natural extension of Season 1, but with a whole new layer of realism.” Meanwhile, Vicky Jessop of the London Evening Standard praised Foster’s script, noting that the banter “remains sparkly and fizzy and makes the 20‑minute episode runtimes fly by.”
Other voices echoed similar sentiment. The Australian’s Joseph Carbone called the show “very watchable,” and FandomWire’s M.N. Miller declared it “still smart, still funny, and still irresistible as ever.” Even reviewers who were less enthusiastic—a C‑grade critic who lamented “missed opportunities” and a 6/10 from Carbone—still acknowledged the series’ charm.
Where the Show Stumbles: Repetition and Predictability
Not every line of feedback was glowing. ScreenRant’s Brennan Klein highlighted a recurring critique: many critics felt the season grew repetitive as the couple emerged from their honeymoon bubble. A Variety piece cited by CBR described the series as “the TV equivalent of an earworm that gets stuck in your head, even if the song’s substance leaves no lasting impact.” The consensus is clear—while the humor and chemistry remain strong, the narrative sometimes leans on familiar beats.
Still, most reviewers agree the strengths outweigh the flaws. Decider’s Hope Sloop summed it up succinctly: “From start to finish, the new season is laugh‑out‑loud funny, heart‑warming, and beyond relatable.” This blend of affection and critique is typical for a show walking the fine line between sentimentality and satire.
The Cultural Hook: Secular Meets Jewish Traditions
What sets Nobody Wants This apart isn’t just the romance; it’s the way the series explores cultural friction. Joanne’s sex‑podcast world collides with Noah’s rabbinical duties, creating a backdrop for jokes that land because they feel authentic. Wenlei Ma of The Nightly (AU) observed that “the most important propulsive element is how people feel rather than what they’re doing,” a point that resonates with audiences navigating their own identity mash‑ups.
These themes have contributed to the show’s strong audience numbers, though exact streaming data remains private. Still, social‑media chatter on Twitter and Instagram shows a surge in #NobodyWantsThis memes each week after episode drops, indicating a healthy buzz that extends beyond critical circles.
Looking Ahead: Will Season 3 Arrive?
Netflix hasn’t officially green‑lit a third season yet, but the rapid renewal after Season 1—just weeks after its September 2024 debut—suggests the platform sees long‑term value. Executive‑producer Kristen Bell, who also runs her own production company, hinted in a recent interview that talks are “in the early stages.” If the Certified Fresh momentum holds, we could see a Season 3 announcement by early 2026.
Either way, the series has carved out a niche for itself: a bite‑size rom‑com that tackles cultural nuance with humor, all while delivering the kind of quick‑laugh pacing that keeps binge‑watchers coming back for more.
Key Facts
- Release date: October 23, 2025 (Netflix)
- Rotten Tomatoes score: 88‑89 % Certified Fresh
- Season 2 episodes: 12, each ~20 minutes
- Lead cast: Kristen Bell & Adam Brody
- Creator/executive producer: Erin Foster
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the Rotten Tomatoes rating for Season 2 compare to Season 1?
Season 1 closed with an impressive 95 % critics score, while Season 2 currently sits at 88‑89 % Certified Fresh. The dip reflects a mix of praise for the writing and some criticism about repetitiveness, but both scores place the series solidly in the upper‑tier of streaming rom‑coms.
What are the main themes explored in Season 2?
Beyond the usual romantic hijinks, the second season delves deeper into cultural clash—particularly the secular‑Jewish dynamic between Joanne and Noah. It also examines how couples navigate life after the honeymoon, highlighting both the humor and tension that arise when traditions meet modern relationships.
Will there be a Season 3, and when might it arrive?
Netflix has not confirmed a third season, but industry insiders note that the rapid renewal after Season 1 and the strong Certified Fresh rating for Season 2 make a continuation likely. If green‑lit, a Season 3 premiere could land in early 2026.
How have audiences responded compared to critics?
While precise streaming numbers are private, audience scores on Rotten Tomatoes sit around 82 % for Season 2, only slightly lower than the 85 % for Season 1. Social media buzz and meme circulation suggest viewers are engaged and generally appreciative of the show’s humor and cultural relevance.
Who are the key creative forces behind the series?
The series is the brainchild of Erin Foster, who serves as creator and executive producer. Lead stars Kristen Bell and Adam Brody also act as executive producers, bringing personal insight to their characters.